Menu of The Cup - Bethlehem in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

The Cup - Bethlehem, nestled at 2 Farrington Square in Bethlehem, PA, stands out as a vibrant local ice cream shop with a nostalgic charm that transports visitors back to the 1980s. This family-owned gem, located near Lehigh University, offers an impressive array of flavors and ice cream experiences that cater to all tastes.

One of the undeniable highlights of their menu is the Peanut Butter Cookie ice cream served in a perfectly crisp waffle cone, often adorned with colorful sprinkles. The rich, creamy texture of their ice cream marries beautifully with the slight crunch of the cone, creating a delightful balance of flavors and textures. Fans of classic sweets will also find the Chocolate Chip Ice Cream a comforting choice, while the Strawberry Cheesecake flavor delivers a luscious, fruity tang that pairs wonderfully with their smooth base.

Beyond traditional scoops, The Cup - Bethlehem is known for its diverse options like soft serve dipped in various coatings and indulgent gelato, catering to those who appreciate both texture and depth of flavor. The inclusion of unique offerings such as Matcha provides a refreshing, slightly bitter contrast to the sweeter flavors, demonstrating their commitment to diversity and catering to modern palates.

The generous portioning is worth noting, as customers often leave well-satisfied; even the medium sizes brim with enough ice cream to delight the senses without overwhelming. This generosity enhances the value and deepens the enjoyment, turning each visit into a memorable treat.

What truly elevates The Cup - Bethlehem is not just the quality and variety of its ice cream but also the vibrant atmosphere. The retro arcade games add a playful edge, evoking a blend of nostalgia and fun that perfectly complements the sweet offerings. The owner’s warm hospitality and the friendly staff make every visit feel personal and welcoming, setting this place apart.

In summary, The Cup - Bethlehem is a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic, generous, and flavor-rich ice cream experience, wrapped in a charming retro setting. Whether you’re indulging in a classic cookie-infused cone or exploring their seasonal and unique flavors, this shop promises satisfaction on every spoonful.